MTA Crash Bug

[Slay]

Hi,

My games is crashing could someone tell me where the error would be

_____________________________________________________________________________________

Version = 1.5.8-release-20779.0.000
Time = Fri Jan 15 19:16:18 2021
Module = C:\Program Files\Rockstar Games\GTA San Andreas\gta_sa.exe
Code = 0xC0000005
Offset = 0x000DFE92

EAX=00695772  EBX=0402C0B6  ECX=0011E2AA  EDX=19F878D8  ESI=3267B27A
EDI=1A9AE000  EBP=0402BE78  ESP=0177FD20  EIP=004DFE92  FLG=00210203
CS=0023   DS=002B  SS=002B  ES=002B   FS=0053  GS=002B
_____________________________________________________________________________________

[Dutchman101]

From https://wiki.multitheftauto.com/wiki/Famous_crash_offsets_and_their_meaning:

So, the reason for crashes with gta_sa.exe offset 0x000DFE92 and 0x000DFF90 is: bad sound mods. Re-install a clean version of GTA.

@Slay

[Slay]

Thanks for the information.

@Dutchman101

[Slay]

problem, what would it be this time? 
@Dutchman101

Version = 1.5.8-release-20802.0.000
Time = Tue Feb  2 01:50:41 2021
Module = C:\Program Files\Rockstar Games\GTA San Andreas\gta_sa.exe
Code = 0xC0000005
Offset = 0x002FEC20

EAX=17F61E80  EBX=00000010  ECX=17F61E90  EDX=29C74790  ESI=29C74780
EDI=00000010  EBP=00000200  ESP=0177F980  EIP=006FEC20  FLG=00210202
CS=0023   DS=002B  SS=002B  ES=002B   FS=0053  GS=002B

[Dutchman101]

2 hours ago, Slay said:

problem, what would it be this time? 
@Dutchman101

Version = 1.5.8-release-20802.0.000
Time = Tue Feb  2 01:50:41 2021
Module = C:\Program Files\Rockstar Games\GTA San Andreas\gta_sa.exe
Code = 0xC0000005
Offset = 0x002FEC20

EAX=17F61E80  EBX=00000010  ECX=17F61E90  EDX=29C74790  ESI=29C74780
EDI=00000010  EBP=00000200  ESP=0177F980  EIP=006FEC20  FLG=00210202
CS=0023   DS=002B  SS=002B  ES=002B   FS=0053  GS=002B

This crash (offset 0x002FEC20) is caused by game mods as well, more specifically it most likely are roadsign texture/model mods. Like for example, a corrupted or missing "roadsignfont" texture in particle.txd (which is located in GTA San Andreas\models folder) can cause it.

We aren't sure whether or not server mods like that (a server running bad roadsign textures) can also cause players to crash, if their GTA isn't modded.

If yours is modded, it's just another example that game stability isn't guaranteed, unless you play with the original unmodded game. It is easier to once again re-install your GTA, instead of spending time to find the problem in ways i described (roadsign mods).

if it's not modded, contact the server owner with this information

[Slay]

8 hours ago, Dutchman101 said:

This crash (offset 0x002FEC20) is caused by game mods as well, more specifically it most likely are roadsign texture/model mods. Like for example, a corrupted or missing "roadsignfont" texture in particle.txd (which is located in GTA San Andreas\models folder) can cause it.

We aren't sure whether or not server mods like that (a server running bad roadsign textures) can also cause players to crash, if their GTA isn't modded.

If yours is modded, it's just another example that game stability isn't guaranteed, unless you play with the original unmodded game. It is easier to once again re-install your GTA, instead of spending time to find the problem in ways i described (roadsign mods).

if it's not modded, contact the server owner with this information

I understand, is that I have a modified gta to improve the fps on servers, would you have any reduced gta3.img without crash / bugs?
 

[SpecT]

4 hours ago, Slay said:

I understand, is that I have a modified gta to improve the fps on servers, would you have any reduced gta3.img without crash / bugs?
 

As @Dutchman101 said the game stability isn't guaranteed by using modified files (in your case gta3.img file). So we can't provide you a "reduced" gta3.img file.
In order to play it without crashes it would be best to play it with original game files.

GTA:SA is not a high demanding game for nowadays PCs and it should run just fine on an average PC if there aren't any super heavy mods installed.
If you have low performance on all servers then you should rather consider upgrading your PC than using reduced texture quality mods.
 

[Slay]

4 hours ago, SpecT said:

As @Dutchman101 said the game stability isn't guaranteed by using modified files (in your case gta3.img file). So we can't provide you a "reduced" gta3.img file.
In order to play it without crashes it would be best to play it with original game files.

GTA:SA is not a high demanding game for nowadays PCs and it should run just fine on an average PC if there aren't any super heavy mods installed.
If you have low performance on all servers then you should rather consider upgrading your PC than using reduced texture quality mods.
 

Okay, if you can't provide an edited gta3 I understand thanks.

[Dutchman101]

@SlayUpload your particles.txd file, and i will restore purely the roadsign texture in it to default. Then you can try if it stops the crashes. This is a last effort way to preserve the modded GTA installation you have right now and still play.

But as you can see, even if it does, there is no guarantee that other GTA crashes won't appear next.

Btw, low FPS issues are easily caused by playing on unoptimized servers - of which there are plenty on MTA. Modded GTA installations that promise better FPS won't really have an impact if the lag you're experiencing is of that nature.. then you can only find other servers to play on, or yes, get a better PC.

[Slay]

@Dutchman101

Where is the error located

________________________________________________________________________________________________
Version = 1.5.8-release-20802.0.000
Time = Fri Mar 19 01:31:58 2021
Module = C:\Program Files\Rockstar Games\GTA San Andreas\gta_sa.exe
Code = 0xC0000005
Offset = 0x011630FE

EAX=00009798  EBX=428A65C8  ECX=428AFFFC  EDX=24875B50  ESI=0000E6BB
EDI=00279000  EBP=89AF8250  ESP=0177FBC8  EIP=015630FE  FLG=00010216
CS=0023   DS=002B  SS=002B  ES=002B   FS=0053  GS=002B
________________________________________________________________________________________________
 

Edited March 19, 2021 by Slay

[Dutchman101]

13 hours ago, Slay said:

@Dutchman101

Where is the error located

________________________________________________________________________________________________
Version = 1.5.8-release-20802.0.000
Time = Fri Mar 19 01:31:58 2021
Module = C:\Program Files\Rockstar Games\GTA San Andreas\gta_sa.exe
Code = 0xC0000005
Offset = 0x011630FE

EAX=00009798  EBX=428A65C8  ECX=428AFFFC  EDX=24875B50  ESI=0000E6BB
EDI=00279000  EBP=89AF8250  ESP=0177FBC8  EIP=015630FE  FLG=00010216
CS=0023   DS=002B  SS=002B  ES=002B   FS=0053  GS=002B
________________________________________________________________________________________________

I already advised you to look at the page Famous crash offsets and their meaning, please do so.

But i will quote it 1 last time for you, from the page about that crash offset (0x011630FE):

This crash is a result of problems with collision models. It might be due to unoptimized collisions that your PC (or MTA's technical limits, due to bad server mods) cannot handle, or due to corrupt collision models. Our first advise would be to ensure that your GTA is unmodded, and otherwise to ask server owner to identify and resolve issues with bad collision models.

I feel like it's a better idea for you to play without a heavily modded GTA installation, than to constantly run into crashes and asking for help here. Your mods apparently are making your game very unstable, or unoptimized for your PC specs (e.g this crash could be that).

Like others have reminded you of, play without mods for a good and qualitative MTA experience.